The Reality Check

This page is intended for people who are just starting or thinking about starting Japanese.

I recently took the highest level of the Japanese Language Proficiency Test, and I've been studying Japanese on and off for five years. I meet a lot of people who are thinking about getting started in Japanese who are seeking advice. I've collected the best nuggets of wisdom I've found in my pursuit of Japanese, and I'll share them with you here.

Point 0: Have a Clear Goal

A lot of people want to "learn Japanese." But the first step to learning Japanese is to decide for yourself what "learning Japanese" means. Does it mean watching anime without subtitles (if so, you're at the wrong site, by the way)? Does it mean picking up girls (also, you're at the wrong site, but here's a free tip: the Japanese girls who will be interested in you can all basically speak some level of English anyway, so there's no real reason for you to study Japanese)? Does it mean reading graduate level texts for research (welcome home)? Or becoming fluent enough to work doing a job other than teaching English in Japan?

Unfortunately, a lot of people who want to learn Japanese don't know any foreign languages. This is unfortunate because if you haven't learned a foreign language, you don't really have an idea of the difficulty and the problems encountered in actually learning a foreign language. And, for various reasons, Japanese is more difficult than a fair number of other languages.

What does this mean for you? It means that if you want to succeed in mastering Japanese to some level, it will help a lot in advance if you know what that level is, so that you can take steps toward it. Saying "I want to know everything" is not very helpful; it's much better to say "I want to read the Tale of Genji in its original form; I want to understand the speeches of politicians when I'm not even paying close attention; and I want to be able to write novels on my own." If you set specific goals, no matter how lofty, it will be easier to measure your progress, and that-- measuring your progress-- will probably become one of the greatest motivators for you.

The road to fluency is long and has many pitfalls. Many start but few succeed. A lot of people are intrigued by this difficulty, and I must admit not so long ago so was I. But, if you do in fact want to succeed, a little planning will go a long way toward your future success.

Also, it's important to understand at the outset that, for various reasons that will become apparent as you learn Japanese, the spoken and written language are quite different, and at the higher levels somewhat independent of each other. In other words, you may be able to understand everything in a college textbook but not what kids say, or the reverse. So, if you have your goals clear at the outset, you can make sure you end up with the abilities you want.

Point 1: Take a Class to Start

A lot of people want to learn Japanese through self study. That's great! I did all of my preparation for the Japanese Language Proficiency Tests (hereafter, "JLPT") on my own. However, self study is no way to begin learning a language.

Language is, at its heart, a way of communication. You can't learn to speak by talking only to yourself. Starting from tapes is lonely and frustrating. As long as you're at least a high school student, with some luck you should be able to find some language class somewhere nearby where you live. In those cases where you can't, I think distance learning is a much better option than doing it all alone.

Japanese can get particularly hairy for native speakers of English. Having a teacher to guide you through the first steps and give you a strong foundation in the basic grammar and structure of the language will insure that when you do self study later, you will be moving in the right direction and spend your time studying in an effective way.

If you insist on doing everything yourself, I wish you the best of luck, but I have yet to meet someone who went from zero to fluent without taking a significant number of classes.

Point 2: Avoid Romaji

Avoid romaji (Japanese written in the Roman alphabet). Learn how to use it so that you can correctly understand the occasional store sign written only in romaji, and then promptly move on to the real Japanese writing system. Japanese people use romaji to write their names, strange advertisements, and little else. For everything else they use the Japanese writing system, and if you want to learn Japanese, you should do. Do as the Romans in Rome, but as the Japanese in Japan.

Point 3: Avoid Over-translating

Japanese and English grew up on opposite sides of the world. For that reason, a lot of even very basic expressions don't literally translate in a sensible fashion. Trying to translate everything you learn in Japanese to English will only be possible for the first few months of study anyway, so it's a habit you should rid yourself of as fast as you can. Most of the foreigners I know who sound like idiots in Japanese sound that way because they constantly literally translate English expressions directly into Japanese, which will make no sense to your average Japanese speaker.

Instead, learn the gist of what the expression means, how to pronounce it correctly, and on what kinds of occasions people use it. But don't spend a lot of time translating back and forth between Japanese and English.

Point 4: Learn the Correct Stroke Order for the Kanji

I don't recommend rushing to learn the kanji. However, when you do learn the kanji, it's very important to learn the correct stroke order. Anyway, think of it this way: if you're going to spend hundreds of hours to learn to write a few thousand characters, you might as well spend the time to learn to do it correctly.

To learn the stroke order, you can either get a book that teaches it or, better, learn the priniciples from a Japanese teacher and just consult a book when you find the occasional very strangely shaped kanji. Most of the kanji are made out of simple parts, called radicals, so really you only need to learn how to make about 200 characters and you can write most of the rest correctly after that.

There are three big advantages of learning the correct stroke order: your kanji will still look relatively good when you write them quickly; people will be impressed; and you can use the stroke order rules to easily look up unknown kanji in a dictionary. The last point is by far the most important.

Point 5: Take It Slow and Have Fun

I read a lot on the Internet at self study sites (not unlike this one) that talk about finding "the fastest way" and "the most efficient method." While you will find plenty of that kind of discussion even at this site, I think it's important to remember that language is communication. It is not, in the end, learning thousands of new words and rules of grammar; it is being able to share your ideas with people, and learning new things expressed in ways you might not have thought of before.

So take it slow, and have fun. Of course, you should study in an efficient fashion. But don't obsess about efficiency. Even if you study for several hours a day, it will take you a few years or more to reach practical fluency, and even more to eliminate the mistakes that come from being a non-native speaker. If you think about that from the beginning, you'll just get depressed, and not want to study Japanese. But unless you're studying Japanese for some frivolous reason, you should be able to enjoy the long journey toward fluency.

There is, of course, another concern here; most of the passionate beginners burn out in Japanese. They are inspired by the difficulty, but in the end the difficulty of Japanese is not that it requires tremendous intelligence to speak, but rather that it requires tremendous (and sometimes tedious) time spent in study to master. When people find out that Japanese is just another human language spoken by human beings, the banality of it all drives them away. So it's better to rid your head of such delusions before you start.

That said, I wish you the best of luck! Check out a few more tips for beginners, and feel free to ask questions in the forums.

Have fun!

Beginning with the end in mind is important, I agree. And aiming for lofty goals is good too, especially if those goals involve productive communication with others through speaking and writing, not just the passive skills reading and listening.

Every point along the journey is just as valid as the last through, I reckon. For some people starting out, a small goal like memorising the kana is just as useful as learning to write remarkable handwritten letters to close friends.

Just so long as you are flexible to adapt your learning strategies to your current level and you're always aiming higher there is not much chance of getting stuck in a rut.

Humans are born to learn languages. It's all about unlocking our hidden potential and not getting hung up on the method. Enjoy!

Right on

You didn't mention much on Kanji.

Kanji makes the learning process exponentially faster.

Learn Kanji from the start (and not from the damn Heisig garbage). Learn like an advanced Japanese child. They don't learn all the Kanji before they can speak nor do they adopt garbage stories. Your smarter than a child, learn speaking and writing at the same time.

I learnt Kanji just by rote learning words. I think Kaeru's method is better than this and the best I've heard, sentences. You learn context and pronunciation. Kanji is not this horror everyone makes out to be, and don't believe the garbage that even Japanese people don't know their own language, if that were the case they would have adopted a purely phonetic alphabet long long ago. Japanese people know their own language.

After setting your goal, choose whether knowing how to write the Kanji is necessary. Maybe for you just reading the Kanji is enough. If you do learn to write it, don't make my mistake, learn stroke order. My school consisted mainly of Chinese and Korean students (who were born before the Korean kanji was phased out of schools). School was throwing 20+ kanji at me everyday, I chose getting full marks rather than writing correctly. I know a ball park stroke order but when I right it on the white board my teachers cry on the inside (ha ha, sorry 谷本先生).

In the begining, you might only be able to retain 15 words a day, but once you know about 600+ Kanji you can learn/retain 30 - 40+ words a day (I'm not a fast learner, I'd say my memory is below average). Also knowing Kanji allows you to make up words with high accuracy. For example, Just by knowing the work 洋楽(ようがく) I could guess there was a word 洋画(ようが). Similarly, by learning 和風(わふう) I guessed there was a word 洋風(ようふう). This works the opposite way too. I knew the word 長所(ちょうしょ) but understood someone immediatley when they used the word 短所(たんしょ).

Jouyou Kanji has absolutley no meaning. In school you didn't just learn the words they taught you, you learnt words you read in books, heard on TV, used by other people etc. In the begining choose your battles concerning which kanji to learn, at an intermediate level, learn every Kanji you see and unless its extrememely rare, learn to write it, else just learn to recognize it (e.g. 龜 (かめ)).

If your goal is to read manga or watch anime without subtitles don't bother with Japanese. Seriously, to learn a language just for anime and manga is an insult to Japanese culture and a garuntee for failure. Imagine someone who wanted to learn english purely to watch the simpsons. Enjoy manga and anime, don't make it a goal.

Insult?

I think you're being too harsh in this comment. Isn't it reasonably common for non-English speakers to acquire some basic English from watching English movies and TV? As a native English speaker, I wouldn't consider this an insult to English-language culture. To me, it is hyperbolic to suggest that learning anything could be an insult to anyone. Having realistic expectations is a completely different matter.

Stroke Order

Thanks. I forgot about mentioning stroke order, but I certainly agree. I've added it to the main article.

Cheers,
Kaeru

Taking classes

Great writing. I agree with most of it, and I find "Avoid Over-translating and Romaji" especially interesting since I make fansubs lol :). Your point do stand. I try not to translate literally, but grasp the gist of the Japanese, then reexpressing the lingering transient thought using English as if I've never heard the original Japanese sentence.

Anyway, I've studied for around 5 years now and I took level 1 JLPT last Desember. I never enrolled any classes, but I do ask questions on forums such as Tae Kim's japanese site from the onset and that is indispensable. Right now, I still ask questions but mostly on Japanese IRCs, directly to the language overlords.

However, I must admit that speaking is my worst ability since I virtually have no one to practice it with.

So, studying alone is a definite no no. But with the right effort I think you can get your footing and proceed to an advanced level without taking any classes, since some sort of guidance can be obtained easily nowadays outside classes.

(I must say that I'm an Indonesian and the rudimentary phonological stuffs like the pronunciation is relatively a piece of cake for our tounge. Also, I can grasp English quite well since I grew up in Australia, so my existing knowledge of those two pretty different languages must've helped me somehow in learning another language)

I'm not saying that it's better to not take classes at the beginning. I would If I had the spare cash back then. However I can attest that it's possible (I'm far from fluent, but I do know some stuffs :) )

I've been studying Japanese

I've been studying Japanese for about 4 years now, and feel I haven't made any progress. You're correct in setting realistic goals and working toward them. One of my goals is to read Murakami Haruki books in the original Japanese. My boyfriend loves another author, and his books haven't been translated into English. This just adds more incentive to the original goal.

I keep getting asked if learning Japanese is difficult. My response is it's time consuming. It's not like English in which you have to learn 26 characters. There's 2000+ characters in which to learn! The only thing I find difficult is to find people who'll actually speak to you in Japanese without them switching to English mid-sentence. I've actually had others run away just to find someone who can speak English!! >_<

After taking JLPT level 3, I now make more time during the day devoted to studying. It may be either listening to a podcast, watching TV or playing a video game in addition to reading books. Anything helps!!

talking in Japanese to Japanese

I've made the same unfortunate experience.
Japanese people can "almost" never look at a non-asian looking person and speak normal Japanese.
People are extremely stubborn and will refuse to speak Japanese to me and use English instead even though I tell them that I am not a native speaker of English.
Frustrating...
But to live in Japan, there is still no way around learning Japanese.

NihongoPeraPera Store

* Buy iTunes Japan Gift Codes.

* Buy Sony PSN Japan Gift Codes.

* Buy Japanese Microsoft Points.

* Buy Japanese Nintendo Points.

* Shop at Amazon Japan.
Clicking the Amazon link gives NihongoPeraPera a small referral on your purchases at no additional cost to you. Support NihongoPera and enjoy great Japanese merchandise!

E-mail Newsletter

Want to receive an e-mail when this site is updated? Subscribe to the updates blog! (I will not use your address for any other purpose, nor share it.)

Enter your Email


Preview